(The Brownie Promise Badge)
So after the Promise consultation I blogged about a couple of months ago, the new Girlguiding Promise has recently been revealed.
The Girlguiding promise changes from this:
I promise that I will do my best,
to love my God,
to serve the Queen and my Country,
To help other people,
and to keep the (Brownie) Guide law
Or for Rainbows: “I promise that I will do my best, to love my God and to be kind and helpful”
To this:
I promise that I will do my best:
To be true to myself and develop my beliefs,
To serve the Queen and my community,
To help other people
and
To keep the (Brownie) Guide Law.
Or for Rainbows: “I promise that I will do my best, to think about my beliefs and to be kind and helpful.”
When put like that it seems a relatively minor change really – but what’s less important is the magnitude of the change, and of more importance is its meaning.
I’ll be honest – when I first heard that the Promise was potentially changing, I was a bit unsure. I, along with many others I’m sure, thought that it works perfectly well, so why change it? But then after the initial thoughts I considered what a change to the promise would actually mean. As I did this, and read the suggestions as I filled in the Promise consultation, I realised that actually, change can be good. I think sometimes society is a bit reactionary – change? why would we do such a thing? which probably made many people initially unsure of a change to something as important to Girlguiding as the Promise. However I’m sure that like myself many people delved into the idea further and reached an informed conclusion as to whether they were in favour or not.
Personally, after thinking it over I realised that taking the word God out of the promise was probably going to encourage a wider membership group to join/say the Promise. And this is exactly what is needed – Girlguiding is not, and never has been (as many people think) a religious organisation. And because of this, we do not want to discriminate against those who aren’t sure about their religious beliefs, for those who have none, or for those who simply don’t want to include them in their promise. The new line “To be true to myself and develop my beliefs” encompasses a wide spectrum, and it can be interpreted by each individual who makes their promise. These beliefs can be religious, or not, they can be about society, the individual, anything! But what I think the promise is saying is that you should be true to yourself, and if you hold a belief then you shouldn’t be ashamed of it, you should act accordingly. Which I think is a pretty good thing to suggest. Of course you don’t want to offend those who are religious, but this is not the intention. The way I see it, this is opening the Promise to a wider range of people and is not excluding those who don’t want to make a Promise about God. And I can’t see why widening the Promise to include everyone is a bad thing.
Removing the word God from the Promise is summed up very nicely here http://www.independent.co.uk/voices/comment/the-girl-guides-have-nothing-to-do-with-religion-and-they-never-have-done-8665048.html by Gail Edmans.
The second change is simply to the word community. This again is a change that I like. I think it’s much easier to explain to our members, some of the 7 year olds I’ve met struggle to understand with the concept of serving the Queen and their country, I think it all sounds very adult like to them. Using the word community, in my opinion makes this part of the promise more accessible to our younger members above all others. Their community is all around them every day, it’s a lot easier for them to get to grips with being of service to the small community in which they live than with the country as a whole, which seems massive to many of the Girls.
So in short I think the change to the Promise is actually a good thing. There’s been a lot of controversy of people thinking this is “political correctness gone mad” and that this is a sign of the secularisation of this country. But people are failing to look past the stereotype of what they think Girlguiding is about, and really think about what changing the Promise means. Many people are against changing the Promise at all, but what they realise is that this isn’t actually the first time, and quite possibly won’t be the last. Staying modern and relevant to today’s girls is going to require changing alongside society. Something as important as the Promise has to be accessible to the widest possible range of members. Like anything, you cannot ever hope to please everybody. What you have to do is try to please as many people as you can, which I certainly hope is what the new Promise manages to do. I think it may take some people a while to get used to it, especially those who have been members of Girlguiding for a large number of years. But I think that Girlguiding has succeeded in making a Promise for all.
All views my own. If you want to know more about the Promise, you can read the official Girlguiding FAQ’s here http://girlguiding.org.uk/about_us/key_information/promise_faqs.aspx